The King’s Speech (2010 – Blu-Ray)

In the past, all a King had to do was look respectable in uniform and not fall off his horse!”

In a contrary way I’ve probably avoided watching ‘The King’s Speech’ until now just because it’s had so, so many awards and so much effusive praise heaped on it, when I thought it looked a little bit over rated from the trailer.  After viewing it I find that my suspicions were bang on.  It’s a film heaving with many flaws yet is a pleasant enough watch and not at all a waste of 2 hrs.

First to the flaws; The usually reliable Timothy Spall is awful as Churchill when there are so many stocky British thesps that could have taken the part (Albert Finney anyone?).  Also Churchill seems awkwardly shoehorned into a number of scenes about the pre-WWII plot even though he isn’t actually Prime Minister at the time the film takes place. Colin Firth looks far older than George VI was at the time, indeed at 50 he is between 10 and 20 years too old depending on the point in the plot.  The cinematography is dreadful featuring garish Digital colour correction (A particular irritant of mine) rendering some shots in cartoonish colours.  The film “Climaxes” with a similarly colour drenched CGI crowd shot from the Royal balcony which betrays its limited budget.  There is a massive plot hole caused by an early scene where the prince instantly pre-records a perfect speech, which leads to questions of why he spends the rest of the film stuttering through a series of needlessly stressful live broadcasts. But, the chief problem I found was that I’d already seen the movie before in 1994 and it was called ‘The Madness of King George’.  The plot is essentially identical, Royal has problems that none of the regular quacks can cure then in walks impudent new physician with quirky ideas who proceeds to cure said Royal and in doing so metaphorically heals the nation.  That Alan Bennett written movie cast a large shadow over almost every moment of ‘The King’s Speech’.

Now to the films good parts; Firth while too old gives one of his finest ever performances as a proud Prince crushed by duty, responsibility and fear.  Guy Pierce’s portrayal of the foppish Edward VIII is so spot on that in some shots it’s almost spooky.  Michael Gambon’s brief cameo as George V is magnificent, Derek Jacobi is excellent (If underused) and Geoffrey Rush is of course brilliant as the Prince’s quirky voice coach.  In the end despite the infuriating mix of faults and virtues it’s a rollicking good watch but hardly worth 7 Baftas.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: